Kamel Jedidi, Bernd H. Schmitt, Malek Ben Sliman, and Yanyan Li · Journal of Marketing, 85(5): 22–41, 2021
Abstract
Has marketing academia lost its relevance for marketing practice? To move beyond the long-lasting conceptual debate, this article assesses this question empirically by employing a text-mining methodology on academic marketing articles. We develop version 1.0 of the R2M (Relevance to Marketing) Index and validate it against external measures: the index correlates with relevance measures, such as practice awards and practitioner evaluations of articles, and articles in marketing journals have a higher score than articles in disciplinary journals in psychology and economics. Moreover, we find that articles published in the Journal of Marketing have the highest R2M score followed by Marketing Science, Journal of Marketing Research, and Journal of Consumer Research. We suggest that journal editors and authors use the R2M Index to assess the relevance of an article, and marketing practitioners to identify relevant articles. Because the index will always be a work in progress that requires continuous improvement, we discuss how to overcome limitations by including more journals, designing further safeguards against “gaming the system,” and moving from relevance to business impact.
Tianyi Peng, Melanie Brucks, George Gui, Daniel J. Merlau, Grace Jiarui Fan, Malek Ben Sliman, Eric J. Johnson, Abdullah Althenayyan, Silvia Bellezza, Dante Donati, Hortense Fong, Elizabeth Friedman, Ariana Guevara, Mohamed Hussein, Kinshuk Jerath, Bruce Kogut, Akshit Kumar, Kristen Lane, Hannah Li, Vicki Morwitz, Oded Netzer, Patryk Perkowski, and Olivier Toubia ·Science Advances, 12(36): eaeh8260, 2026
Abstract
Scientists and practitioners are aggressively moving to deploy digital twins—large language model (LLM)-based models of individuals—across social science and policy research. We conducted 19 preregistered studies with 164 diverse outcomes (e.g., attitudes toward hiring algorithms and intention to share misinformation) and compared human responses with those of their digital twins (trained on each person’s previous answers to more than 500 questions). We establish an empirical benchmark for digital twin performance: Digital twins’ answers are only modestly more accurate than those from the (homogeneous) base LLM and correlate weakly with human responses (average correlation coefficient of 0.20). To guide future development, we document five ways in which digital twins distort human behavior: (i) insufficient individuation, (ii) stereotyping, (iii) representation bias, (iv) ideological biases, and (v) hyper-rationality. We make our full dataset and code public as a standardized testbed. Our results caution against premature deployment while laying the groundwork for the transparent, replicable, and iterative science necessary for responsible deployment of digital twins.